Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Monday, 21st July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the n/a site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

I'll name the real killers of Halifax Town



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Johnny Meynell, a Halifax Town fan since a young boy, is angry about the demise of his favourite team. He has closely followed the running of the club. The author of The Definitive Halifax Town AFC gives his personal account of where the blame lies for the collapse of the Shaymen
Now that the dust has settled and the fate of my beloved Halifax Town has been sealed, I feel compelled to air my own thoughts concerning those who have continually driven the club into the ground until they left it and us with nothing.

Of course, with my passion for the history of the club and all that that has entailed, it would be fair to say that the club has never really been successful, and some would argue it should be rightly put to bed. For those supporters who backed Halifax Town through thin and thinner, the view is the complete opposite.

The fan base that at best would be around 1,500 – though of course much higher when a bit of success comes its way – deserved so much more than different boards of directors gave them.

The protracted takeover – that never was – was typical of the way the club has been run, and one wonders now, that even if it had come off, would Bosomworth, Ham and Peacock have made a success of it?

Despite putting in stashes of cash, which, it would be fair to say, kept the club going a little longer, it does seem ironic that the consortium that was going to save Halifax Town in the end killed it.
That will be their legacy, nothing less.

The present crisis was not of their making in the first instance; the debts were already there. But it seems that for the sake of around £8,000, which former chairman Ray Moreland was asking for back, they put the club into administration and therefore gambled with it – and lost.

Why it really took so long for Bosomworth, Ham and Peacock to complete the takeover they sought, only they themselves really know. They wanted a 75 per cent shareholding to have complete control of the club, but surely, having acquired the shares they did (around 61 per cent I believe) they could have formed a board, structured the club, given Moreland his money back, and perhaps money would have come into the club through commercial activity, the selling of a player (Jon Shaw must have been worth a six figure sum) and a run in the FA Cup, not out of the question.

In short, they could have been running the club, given it a bit more time, and the death knell would not have been sounded. Who knows?
The fans themselves often talk of where it all started to go wrong.

It is old ground, I know, when we talk about the period 10 years ago, when, following our greatest achievement in winning the Conference and reclaiming our Football League status, but the return of Jim Brown as chairman was viewed even at the time as disastrous for the club.

He hardly covered himself in glory during his first spell at the club, what with relegation in 1993 and all, but his activity set in motion the chain of events that culminated in the announcement on Friday.

Brown, like those that followed, has a lot to answer for. With much input from his brother-in-law Peter Butler, the Conference-winning team was broken up far too early and the calibre of the players brought in took us down the familiar road of eternal struggle.

The pair of them may feel they have no part to play in Halifax Town's demise; to a man the supporters would think otherwise.

His successor Bob Walker, one feels, had a dream of walking through the divisions with an ex-international in Paul Bracewell.

Didn't Walker promise First Division football within five years of him taking the helm? His expensive running of the club, with average players on vast amounts of money – Andy Woodward and Dominic Ludden spring to mind –- meant only one thing. Debt and no success.

Relegation duly came, yet unlike in 1993, when a team of triers went down fighting, losing league status simply because they were not quite good enough, in 2002 the club was relegated with players who acted like prima donnas and had no real passion for the club. Some of them were just there because of the wages offered them.

The club went into administration, and that would be Bob Walker's legacy. He, like Brown, can't be exonerated from Halifax Town's death.

But there was still life in the club; the board now headed by David Cairns appointed Chris Wilder as manager, and though the CVA the club had to operate under was crippling the club, on the field Wilder came close to giving us back League football in 2006 – just two years ago.

I bet the then chairman Geoff Ralph would have loved that; being entertained in the boardroom of Football League clubs, being in the Big Time. The club was 10 minutes away from winning the Conference play-off final at Leicester, and the step-up looked likely. But our hearts were broken and Hereford won in extra-time.

What amazed all the supporters at the time of that final, in fact on the morning of the game itself, was the total lack of commercial activity. No scarves, pennants, annoying bazookas, play-off final memorabilia. Nothing at all. Well, apart from the non-official stuff from southern-based sellers, who arrived at the Shay three days in advance.

Our suspicions should have been aroused then; no club marketing, no commercial manager, no club shop to speak of. How did Ralph expect the club to sustain itself when it relied totally on income through the gates, and a bit of hoped-for TV money? A board that was once 10- strong was whittled down to one man, and then he pleaded for new investment. Ralph put in much of his own money, and to that we should be grateful. But he knew what Halifax Town was about, and it was his own choice. As it was to run it out of business.

His hopes, as did ours in the end, rested on Bosomworth and Ham. As we all know, it was fruitless.

The club did the business on the field – just – once the 10-point penalty was imposed for entering into administration for the second time in six years (despite the previous CVA not having been paid up), but it was off the field where the biggest game was lost.

How Halifax Town could have been run in the way it was, with us supporters completely unaware of just how grave the situation was, is a disgrace.

Bad enough to think it owed £500,000 to the Inland Revenue. Who didn't do their sums right when the real figure was nearly twice that amount?
The club has been, in the opinion of many, run by amateurs, and as always it is the supporters who have been left with no club.

There is hope, however, that a new club can be formed, possibly three leagues below the Blue Square Premier, and to that end we must embrace the Supporters Trust. Many feel any new club must be run on better lines, run by the fans, for the fans. I feel it is the only way forward.

No more unscrupulous businessmen playing games with a club that has been loved by thousands over the years and sold down the river. We want a club that is run right, possibly named Halifax Town (2008) or Halifax Town FC. For me, with my aforementioned interest in the history of the club, it is imperative that the name lives on.

The King is dead, long live the King.

Courier Comment

The full article contains 1321 words and appears in n/a newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 May 2008 10:13 AM
  • Source: n/a
  • Location: Halifax
 
Prev
1
2
1

Bob Tash,

Club Lane Towers 14/05/2008 09:09:58
Jim Brown should be shot for what he did,ask my mate Terry Sunderland he says what he did by coming back to the club and syphoning funds was barbaric.Terry has now gone and purchased a £100 season ticket to watch Huddersfield Town, another club close to his heart but not has close has Halifax which has ripped his heart out.
2

Barney Rubble,

14/05/2008 09:27:51
Seems a knowledgeable guy and not one mention of the Rugby club ruining the pitch or not putting money in.

This guy knows the real reasons for the Footy not being successful.
3

BT,

0 14/05/2008 10:25:21
Known Johnny a long time, great guy. Can't help feeling putting this in the public domain at this point in time is a misjudgement.
4

Andy Lake,

Swansea 14/05/2008 10:48:17
Cant help but feel bt is right , however much these people are to blame theres nothing anyone can do now, whats done is done, this probably would of beeen better held back until the pheonix has risen and the shaymen return to football
5

JND,

14/05/2008 10:51:31
All of what Johnny says is fair comment but to exclude the Bluesox from any blame is wrong. Their lack of investment when they came to share the stadium directly led to the debts that were run up. When the football club owes 2 builders £200,000 a piece for a stadium they don't own shows the underlying cause.

All the people listed above were at least in some way trying to do the best for the club however badly but the Bluesox just came, demanded, gave nothing and left the Shaymen holding the debts while they squandered the Thrum Hall millions until they went out of business.

If they had upheld their end the stadium would have been completed and the commercial side of both clubs would have been a lot healthier helping both clubs move forward instead of both going out of existence. The football clubs debts would have been smaller and more manageable without the burden of having to carry all the stadium debts as well. Once in the downward spiral the Shaymen were doom, its amazing they lasted so long.
6

Brigantes,

14/05/2008 10:55:18
Well said Johnny.There is no need to include the Rugby in the criticism although they should have put at least something towards ground development.All fault lies at the door of the spurious businessmen who have destroyed Halifax Town.
7

Fax fan,

14/05/2008 11:28:18
JND, Firstly there is no longer a rugby team called blue sox. Secondly, if your going to make outlandish comments on these pages, then at least get the facts right. If you researched the facts you will find that Fax did not get nowhere near any millions you claim the club got, from the sale of thrum hall. And with regards squandering, do you actually know what the money was spent on? Because i do, and squandered it was not.
Perhaps you could also tell us what demands the rugby club made, or is that another one of your stories?
True Fax fans have nothing but the utmost support and sympathy for the shaymen, yet certain individuals still find it necessary to point the finger of blame at Halifax Rugby League club.
HXRLFC were not running the accounts of Halifax Town, HXRLFC were not accountable for HX Town not paying monies to the inland revenue, and Fax were not the clueless amateurs who were in charge of the club.
Whilst i sympathise deeply with the town fans for the way they have been let down, Halifax town's demise is their own, and nobody else's.
8

Your old Friend,

14/05/2008 11:54:44
great photo
9

JND,

14/05/2008 12:08:55
Fax fan, my comments were in no way aimed at the current rugby league club and I have nothing but best wishes for them in the current season which is why I used the defunct Bluesox title.

But when discussing what has and hasn't affected the football club the transfer of the Bluesox to the Shay and the subsequent stadium development the Bluesox cannot and should not be left out of the factors that have brought the football club to its current plight.

The stadium that was in place when the football club won the conference (ie minus the East Stand) was perfectly adequate for the football club. It did hold back the Bluesox because they could get bigger crowds for certain games in the Super league and consequently the more ambitious plans were moved forward on the back of the football club with as far as most football fans can see no liability taken on by the Bluesox.

In this discussion everything is historical, everyone loves to point the finger at Brown, Walker & Ralph as they should as these are the men who held the reins over each failure of the football club and yes the football club has to and does take the blame for what they have done but the stadium fiasco is what more than anything else has burden the club with cripling debts they couldn't pay and the Bluesox transfer to the Shay is the major catalist for these debts.
10

Barney Rubble,

14/05/2008 15:27:37
JND it's funny that you say that the Bluesox put nothing into the ground as I spoke to an ex-Town Director once who told me that the Bluesox money paid for the new stand near the Halifax car park and the new one with the bar under it.
Prev
1
2

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Today's Vote

Should landlords be able to evict tenants more easily?
Yes
No

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.