Refusing 230-home plan for Calderdale village 'could cost council six figure sum'
Refusing permission for 230 homes in a Calderdale village could cost the council “multiple six figures”, a planning chief has warned.
A majority of Calderdale Council’s planning committee members were considering refusing Keyland Developments Ltd’s outline application – with a more detailed application to come later – to build the homes at land south west of Ellistones Lane in Greetland.
The proposals have been very controversial, with more than 400 objections.
After a lengthy questions session, and hearing from objectors and the developer, they were considering several proposals, including Coun Gordon Thorpe’s that permission be refused, against officers’ recommendation that they be mindful to permit the application.


Coun Thorpe (Reform UK, Ovenden) said he had “serious concerns” about drainage and flood risk relating to the site, about health issues including noise relating to a long-established neighbouring local business, about impacts on the road network and traffic numbers, and impact on nature and biodiversity.
Coun Thorpe said the committee had to be satisfied that impacts of the development could be adequately mitigated.
“Having reviewed evidence, I am not satisfied that those tests have been met,” he said.
But the council’s lead planning officer, Richard Seaman, said members needed to make their decision very carefully.


“What members can’t assume is, that by refusing planning permission today, it will prevent the development from going ahead.
“In all likelihood, the applicant would appeal against refusal – although I should add we would have to refer this to the Secretary of State anyway, we couldn’t actually refuse it at this meeting – but the applicant would appeal against refusal and the council would have to defend every ground of refusal.
“If we fail to put credible evidence forward, the planning inspector, who would consider such an appeal, would in all likelihood award costs against the council.
“Those costs for a public inquiry of this sort of scale would easily run into six figures, could be multiples of six figures,” he said.
Mr Seaman said in terms of defending reasons for refusal, to every point being made by objectors, other representatives and members of the committee where they have asked questions, officers “have been able to provide a clear and cogent response”.
Earlier, objectors including ward councillor Coun Tom Garnett (Reform UK, Greetland) had been very critical and sceptical about responses they received.
But Mr Seaman said: “What you could not do at a public inquiry against considering refusal is simply to turn up at that inquiry and say ‘we’re not convinced, we don’t accept the evidence.’
“Clearly, it’s a significant issue that could have quite major financial consequences for the council,” he said.
Mr Seaman said assessments made by officers had used standard methodologies and for refusal they would have to demonstrate there were methodological errors in these.
Officers had not been able to identify any such errors, he said.
They recommended councillors should be mindful to permit the application subject to planning conditions and legal agreements.
Other proposals included Coun Katie Kimber’s (Lab, Luddenden Foot) to follow officers’ recommendations, and committee Chair, Coun Steve Mycroft’s (Reform UK, Brighouse) proposal that the application should be deferred for the grounds of refusal to be fully explored and explained in a report for a future meeting.
Members agreed to defer the application for this to be prepared.