Councillors' threat to close Calderdale school called in for scrutiny after parents' questions left unanswered
Calderdale Reform are being challenged on a contentious decision which could see the closure of a Calderdale school.
Labour councillors have called in the agreement by cabinet members of Calderdale Council – now run by Reform - to begin a consultation on shutting Colden Junior and Infant School, above Hebden Bridge.
Calling in is a council procedure that pauses a decision before it is put into effect so councillors can examine it and, if concerns remain, ask the cabinet to reconsider.
Calderdale Labour say the move follows cabinet members’ “refusal to answer questions from worried parents”.


As reported by the Courier, several concerned residents were at the cabinet meeting held earlier this month where the school consultation decision was made.
They were expecting to get answers to questions they submitted before the meeting but were left "absolutely flabbergasted” when their questions were not directly answered and, at one point, they and others were ejected from the meeting before being allowed back in.
Instead, they were read a short statement by cabinet member for Children and Young People’s Services Councillor Tim Holden.
Calderdale Labour say calling in the decision – which will mean it is discussed by a council scrutiny panel – should allow councillors to examine several important issues.
These, they hope, will include why the proposed consultation period runs over the Christmas holidays, how the proposal fits with the council’s Small Schools Strategy. how the estimated cost of capital works needed at the school has been calculated, and whether an Equality Impact Assessment has been completed.
Councillor Sarah Courtney (Labour, Hebden Bridge and Todmorden East) said: “Colden is more than just a school. It is an important part of its community and village life.
“We recognise the challenges facing smaller rural schools, but that makes it even more important that every possible option is properly explored before a decision of this magnitude is progressed.
“Our call-in provides an opportunity to scrutinise the evidence, consider the alternatives and ensure the voices of parents, governors, staff and the wider community are heard.
“This is not about avoiding difficult decisions. It is about making sure the right decision is reached, for the right reasons, following a thorough and transparent process.”
Cabinet members were told in a report before their meeting that Colden Junior and Infant School currently has just 35 children enrolled, and no pupils in its Reception class.
The situation means recruiting and retaining staff is becoming “increasingly difficult”, the report added.
In addition, a council assessment has identified around £332,000 of “urgent condition works” needed to maintain the school building “so that it can remain safe and operational”.
In his statement, Coun Holden thanked everyone who had submitted questions and said proposing a consultation on the school’s closure “is not a decision that anyone takes lightly".
"All views submitted through the consultation process will be taken into consideration before any decision can be taken over whether to publish formal statutory notices to close,” he added.
Meantime, Calderdale’s Labour, Green and Liberal Democrat group leaders have united to also call in another controversial cabinet decision – to look for another group to take on Mixenden Activity Centre after the North Halifax Partnership (NHP) bid was rejected.
The rival councillors want answers from Reform, including an explanation as to why a community asset transfer of the centre to NHP - which had been running the centre since it reopened last year – was turned down.
They say council officers have advised that NHP’s business case had met the required criteria.
The Courier has also asked the council this question but has yet to receive a response.