"If you're stood still in this game, you're going backwards" - Town boss McGrath next to try and steer Shaymen to promised land

John McGrathplaceholder image
John McGrath

And so the National League's equivalent of the Impossible Job falls next to John McGrath.

In the end, Thomas Tuchel was unable to complete Project Second Star for England this summer.

McGrath is about to embark on Project Second Promotion, a quarter of a century since Halifax were last in the Football League and nearly 30 years since the only other time The Shaymen ascended into the promised land.

Like waves on a shore, Town have moved both closer and further away from promotion over recent years.

John McGrath during his playing days at Burton Albionplaceholder image
John McGrath during his playing days at Burton Albion

McGrath knows a thing or three about promotion, having achieved it as a player once each with Doncaster, Weymouth and Burton Albion.

Despite play-off finishes with Mickleover and Buxton, he is yet to achieve it in management.

McGrath made more than 400 appearances as a pro, and says it was always in his mind to try being a manager.

"I love coaching, and I love managing players," he says.

"It's your exit strategy from playing full-time. I was lucky enough to work under some really good managers and take some bits from them.

"It was my next natural progression from playing, to try and stay in the game."

McGrath spent longer at Burton Albion - six seasons - than anywhere else as a player, and says his manager there, Nigel Clough, was the best he worked under.

"He made me realise how important a good positive manager as a role model can be.

"I've had plenty of bad ones! But you take a lot from them as well."

McGrath says the main difference between good managers and bad ones is how they make players feel.

"Nigel got the best out of me. I played almost every minute of every game under him," he said.

"You wanted to play for him, he created an environment that was easy to learn in, but it was a winning environment.

"He didn't take any crap, but built a really good squad over the course of 10, 12 years.

"I came into that probably halfway through and into a really stable environment, with a manager who knew what he was doing."

McGrath's first steps into management came at Derbyshire side Mickleover, when he was 36.

"I had a really bad injury that stopped me playing full-time, and then went in to being a player-manager," he said.

"I had some great years there and it was a great grounding for me because that, in theory, was full-time. They had a full-time academy from 16s to 18s, so I oversaw the whole club for that nine years.

"It was a really, really good apprenticeship for me in terms of how to manage upwards, the chairman and the board, and getting styles of play and how to recruit players and deal with budgets."

A little more than a decade on from when he started, McGrath says he has definitely evolved as a manager.

"I think if you're stood still in this game, you're going backwards," he said.

"You need to keep improving, keep making yourself better.

"You have to be able to evolve with the times.

"With each individual player, you can't manage them in one way. "They've all got different traits and personalities, and I'm mindful of that, mindful I've got senior players, young lads, lads who are married, lads who are single.

"It's all a melting pot that you have to manage.

"I'm a better manager now than I was at Mickleover and I'd like to think in seven or eight years time, I'll be better than I am today.

"Every manager will say it can be a lonely place at times, being a manager.

"It's on your head, be it. That's what you sign up to.

"But if you can recognise your flaws and weaknesses, you can regroup and try to make them better."

McGrath relishes his daily contact time with players, and the chance to see hard work during the week become hard-fought points on a matchday.

"I think the best thing is Saturday at three o'clock when you get to watch what you've put into the lads in terms of workload over the week," he said.

"You get to mould the squad in pre-season, pick and choose who you want to sign.

"Obviously there's boundaries and restrictions to that, but the best thing for me is having access to the players on a daily basis."

When asked what type of manager he sees himself as, McGrath said: "I think I'm quite an open manager, I like to create really good environments for players to come and learn.

"I'm not a screamer or a baller, which I think is quite effective when I actually do it because it's warranted.

"I'm quite a laid back manager. I want what's best for my players first and foremost.

"I try and leave players in a better position than when we got them, whether they're with me for a week or for five or six years, I like to improve players.

"But ultimately, I try to see the human side of everything because I think, sometimes, managers just see it as three points, black or white, but there's so much more that goes into managing."

After a decade of evolution in Derbyshire, this is McGrath's biggest season yet as a manager: his first in the fifth tier and, like Town, within touching distance of the Football League.

"It's the highest I've managed and, for me, it's an opportunity to manage a really, really big club in my opinion, in a really, really competitive league," he said.

"It's a league with some massive clubs in now, some massive budgets, some really good managers and some good players.

"I consider this jump up from Buxton and the National League North as a really important one for myself."

Like those before him at The Shay in recent seasons, the talk is of Town fighting for that longed-for, seemingly elusive promotion into League Two, but tinged with a pragmatism about the size of the task.

"I've never shied away from wanting the best for Halifax Town, myself and my players," says McGrath on what would be a successful season.

"I want to win every game we play in.

"Will we do that? No, probably not.

"Will we get beat 3-0 or 4-0 in games? Yes, we will.

"But as long as we see certain improvements throughout the season.

"I'd like to race to 52 points as quickly as I can, which is a good starting point, but then I'd like to cement a play-off place and see where we go from there."

News you can trust since 1853
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice