Family's plan for Calderdale self-build eco-home refused

A Calderdale family who have spent £20,000 trying to replace a derelict barn with a self-build eco-home have had their planning bid refused.

Joe Armitage, 38, and wife Zoe Armitage, 34, bought the site on Pickwood Scar, near Sowerby Bridge, for £190,000, hoping to build a solar powered four-bedroom house, with electric vehicle charging, for themselves and their three children.

Calderdale Council planning officers accepted the proposal would redevelop previously developed land, improve the appearance of the site, help meet housing need, and contribute to Calderdale’s shortage of self-build plots.

The scheme was unanimously supported by neighbours, but officers have refused planning permission due to its distance from services and public transport links, citing “steep gradients” and “poor lighting”, that would lead to an overreliance on private vehicles and “cause harm” to “sustainable travel objectives”.

Joe Armitageplaceholder image
Joe Armitage

Mrs Armitage, who works for Lloyds Bank and drives an electric car, said: “I just don’t understand it. There’s a derelict building here that’s collapsing. The neighbours and community all want it. And the only comeback they have is we are too reliant on private cars.

“We are not trying to redevelop a field. We are trying to rebuild a building. They say they desperately need homes. That’s what’s so annoying.

“We have worked really hard. Always paid our taxes. And now we cannot better the community.”

Having already spent thousands on materials that are sitting unused at the site, Mr Armitage, a builder with his own construction company, wants to meet with Calderdale’s planning officers so he can “work with them” to find a solution.

Plans for the new home show it will be kitted out with solar panelsplaceholder image
Plans for the new home show it will be kitted out with solar panels

“It’s just draining to have to wait this long for an answer and they are not willing to talk to you,” he said.

“I would build it out of mud to have it, but the problem is they are not willing to work with you. It’s just: take your money. I don’t want to be going mad at the council. I just want to work with them.”

Jeremy Thwaite, a 56-year-old account who lives opposite the barn, is among the Pickwood residents who were looking forward to a new home.

“I don’t think there’s anyone who has objected to it. I think it’s just tidying up a bit of an eyesore. [The barn is] only going to get worse. It’s just falling down,” said Mr Thwaite.

Among the public comments on the council’s website, one unnamed resident said they fully supported the application “to convert a dilapidated, ugly, eye-sore of a shed into a beautiful family home”, while another pointed out the current building is “potentially dangerous”.

Other residents called the application a “positive step forward for the area” and said it would “provide an attractive family home and make much better use of the site”.

The latest council decision is the second refusal for the family, who also lost an appeal in June after a planning inspector concluded “harm… would be caused by locating [a] residential development outside a settlement and away from facilities and public transport”.

The Armitage family dispute this, arguing the distances to schools and public transport connections would not put them off walking or cycling.

It is around a half-a-mile walk to the nearest primary school, a combined 40-minute walk and bus to the nearest secondary school, and less than two miles to the nearest supermarket in Sowerby Bridge.

Mrs Armitage also said she already commutes to Leeds regularly from Sowerby Bridge railway station, which also has a direct link to Manchester.

After changes to national planning policy in August that placed greater weight on delivering new homes, including self-build homes, the family re-submitted their application with the assurance Mr Armitage would be the one to build it.

The Armitage family argued the reforms meant the benefits of the scheme should now outweigh concerns about sustainability – which they also say would be mitigated by electric vehicle use and taking a shortcut to a closer bus stop.

They plan to appeal the latest refusal.

Calderdale Council was approached for comment.

News you can trust since 1853
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice