Plight of parents "thrown out" of Calderdale Council meeting raised in Parliament
Calder Valley’s MP says he is “appalled” by the way parents from his constituency were treated at a Calderdale Council meeting – and has raised the matter in Parliament.
Josh Fenton-Glyn has slammed the “throwing out” of parents who were at last week’s cabinet meeting to share their concerns over the threat to close their village school.
As reported by the Courier, several concerned residents were at the meeting expecting to get answers to questions submitted about the potential shutting of Colden Junior and Infant School, above Hebden Bridge.
Instead, they were read a short statement by cabinet member for Children and Young People’s Services Councillor Tim Holden.


Councillors went on to agree that a consultation on closing the school should begin.
The public question time at the meeting lasted around 10 minutes before leader of the council Daniel Sutherland ejected members of the public due to heckles that erupted after he declined to answer a question about Queens Road Neighbourhood Centre in Halifax.
Audience members heckled Coun Sutherland’s approach – ultimately leading him to have all of the public ejected before some were allowed back in.
Speaking in the House of Commons, Labour MP Mr Fenton-Glynn said: “Last week, Calderdale’s Reform-led council announced the consultation into the closure of Colden Junior and Infant School.
"They compounded the distress by throwing parents out of the cabinet meeting where it was decided.
"Does my honourable friend agree with me that parents’ voices and opinions must be central to the future of their children’s education?”
In response, Josh MacAlister – Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Department for Education – said: “I do agree with my honourable friend and I know he is a real champion of local schools within his own community.
"Where the closure of a maintained school is proposed by a local authority, it must follow the relevant statutory process.
"That includes careful consultation before any final decision are made.”
Mr Fenton-Glynn also posted that he was “appalled” by the behaviour of the cabinet.
"Parents deserve to be heard and accountability is important. It is the height of disrespect to voters to avoid scrutiny like this,” he said.
A Calderdale Council spokesperson said the question time slot is not required under the council’s constitution nor the access to information regulations, and it is “within the gift of the leader” to assess the best use of time.
They said previous leaders had modified the sessions based on time constraints with questions not read out and responded to in writing.
The spokesperson also said “some” questions about the school’s potential closure were addressed by the statement and detail in the cabinet report.
On the removal of members of the public, the council claimed Coun Sutherland acted in response to “ongoing disruptive behaviour” and under rules allowing intervention where people disregard rulings, behave improperly or obstruct council business.
Asked whether residents had been given a meaningful opportunity to scrutinise decisions and hold the cabinet to account, the spokesperson replied: “Yes.”
